
One of the perils of making a prequel is that audiences come into the story knowing the ending. For all of the spunky, rebellious spirit on display in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, we’re already aware that Haymitch Abernathy (Joseph Zada) will fail in his attempt to bring down Panem’s vicious annual competition of child murder. We know that the Hunger Games will continue for the better part of a quarter-century after his unexpected victory, and he will be forced to watch dozens of children from District 12 die. And we know that Haymitch himself will despair, becoming a hardened, alcoholic cynic, until an extraordinary girl comes along who breaks the system and changes the world. Yet, somehow, despite all of us being aware of these key facts, Sunrise on the Reaping still manages to craft a story that stands on its own and is as moving as anything in the franchise that’s come before it.
An origin story for Haymitch (played in the original Hunger Games films by Woody Harrelson), Sunrise on the Reaping follows his forced participation in the Second Quarter Quell, the 50th anniversary installment of the infamous Games that includes double the number of tributes from each district and a more lavish, violent arena. (You know, for fun!) Chosen during a Reaping ceremony that’s full of both showbiz cynicism and carefully planned propaganda—he’s forced to film his selection twice over to smooth over a violent moment—Haymitch finds himself on a train to the Capitol alongside his fellow District 12 tributes, including mean girl Maysilee Donner (Mckenna Grace), oddsmaker’s son Wyatt Callow (Ben Wang), and young Louella McCoy (Molly McCann).

Drawn into an alliance with the quietly nerdy Ampert Latier (Percy Daggs IV)—whose father, Beetee Latier (Kelvin Harrison Jr.), is a former victor being forced to mentor his tribute son as punishment for hacking the Capitol’s mainframe—Haymitch learns of a plot to sabotage the arena from the inside, in the hopes of stopping the Games for good. In the wake of a blatant cover-up of a tribute’s death during the parade meant to introduce them to the world—and a dramatic confrontation with President Coriolanus Snow (Ralph Fiennes)—he decides to help. At least then, perhaps, his death can mean something beyond brutal entertainment for the wealthy and complacent. That is, as all fans already know, not at all what happens, but his struggle to make a difference is perhaps all the more meaningful for it.
Though we don’t get to know most of the other tributes as well as we do in Suzanne Collins’ novel, the Games themselves are stunning, held in a Technicolor dream of an arena bursting with sunlight, colorful flowers, and an array of charming woodland creatures that rival a Disney movie. That the arena’s beauty is also its primary danger is part of its charm, forcing tributes to contend with everything from poison flowers and genetically enhanced killer squirrels to a literal volcano. (Yes, really!) Mercifully, the film has toned down several of the book’s more gruesome deaths, but even with less overt gore, Sunrise on the Reaping doesn’t shy away from the horrors these children (remember, Haymitch is just 16!) have to face.
Every Hunger Games story is a tragedy to some degree, but there’s something particularly moving about Haymitch’s journey, which ricochets between optimistic grit and heartbroken frustration, sometimes within the same scene. Sunrise on the Reaping is, at its heart, the story of the long work of change, the many failures and small victories that invariably line the path to a new world. Director Francis Lawrence deftly wrings tension and gravitas from Haymitch’s struggle, and screenwriters Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie smartly never make the outcome of the Games the central point of the story that Sunrise on the Reaping is telling. Instead, the film constantly stresses the differences between the story we’re watching unfold from Haymitch’s perspective and the one that the rest of the characters in the movie are being told. This is a franchise that has always gleefully tackled themes of resistance and self-determination; this film’s focus on propaganda, media manipulation, and perception feels almost uncannily timely.

Zada is excellent throughout: incredibly charismatic, deeply likable, and full of equal parts warm idealism and determined fury. Most impressively, he manages to channel Harrelson without ever resorting to imitation or caricature. He deserves to be a star, and if Haymitch occasionally comes off as maybe a bit too dreamy, it only further underlines the depths to which his future self will fall. The rest of the supporting ensemble is solid, especially Grace’s fierce Maysilee, who you’ll almost certainly wish got more screen time. Multiple famous faces pop up as younger versions of figures with key roles to play in the story’s future, with performers like Elle Fanning and Jesse Plemons adding intriguing context and shading to familiar characters like Effie Trinket and Plutarch Heavensbee.
As with any Hunger Games project, the specter of Katniss Everdeen (Jennifer Lawrence in the original trilogy) is all over this movie, from our glimpses of her parents’ courtship to the mockingjay pin unobtrusively worn by Merrilee Donner in her parents’ sweetshop. While some will likely see this as simple fan service, in Sunrise on the Reaping such references serve a much larger purpose, offering a welcome shot of hope in an otherwise fairly bleak canvas. Yes, Haymitch Abnernathy will fail. But not forever. And that is no small thing.
The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping (PG-13, 158 mins.) opens Nov. 20.